Cast Me Already! - Why Passion Deserves a Place in Community Theatre

Editor’s Note: The following was written by a local performer who lives in a very small theatre community. We’ve decided to respect their request to remain anonymous.

I have never been cast in a community theatre show. Not once. Not as an ensemble member, not as the quirky sidekick, not even as “Man #3” with a single line that gets cut before opening night. But despite this, I keep showing up to auditions, pouring my heart into every monologue, song, and awkwardly improvised bit of stage movement. And I believe—no, I know—that I deserve a role.

Before anyone jumps in with, “Well, maybe you’re just not talented enough,” let’s talk about what community theatre is supposed to be. It’s not Broadway. It’s not even Off-Off-Broadway. It’s meant to be a place for people who love theatre to come together and create something magical. A space where professionals, hobbyists, and newcomers alike share the stage, where passion can sometimes mean more than a perfect belt or impeccable comedic timing.

And yet, community theatre often operates just like professional theatre—casting the same people over and over because they have the “right” look, voice, or experience. If you’re an outsider, breaking in feels impossible. But isn’t the whole point of community theatre to welcome everyone who loves the craft?

I get it—talent matters. Of course, directors want to put on the best show possible. But I’d argue that desire should count for something, too. The people who keep showing up, who support productions even when they aren’t cast, who genuinely want to be a part of the experience—those people deserve a shot. They are the ones who will stay late at rehearsal, promote the show to every coworker and Facebook friend, and bring boundless enthusiasm night after night.

I may not be the best singer. I may not have the dance skills of a seasoned triple threat. But I am someone who loves theatre, who shows up, and who refuses to let a string of rejections keep me away. If community theatre is really about community, then it should recognize the value of persistence and passion alongside raw ability.

And let’s not forget—there are so many different roles in theatre. Not every character has to be the strongest vocalist or the most agile dancer. Sometimes, a show just needs someone who will give their all, who will be a team player, who will bring joy and enthusiasm to every rehearsal.

So I’ll keep auditioning. I’ll keep learning. And one day, when I finally step on that stage, I’ll know I’ve earned it—not just because I was cast, but because I never gave up on the idea that I belonged there.